The Most Comfortable Boots For Women That Score High On Style And Comfort (2024)

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: 3 total, including Black and Dark Brown | Materials: Recycled polyester, nylon and elastane

For a pick that’s soft, stretchy and comfortable, Everlane’s The Glove Boot pass all our tests. The ribbed fabric is made from a combination of recycled polyester (in particular, recycled plastic bottles), nylon and elastane for comfort and durability. And, unlike leather, knit fabric stretches with your foot, which is great for all-day wear. Reviewers also love the 2-inch heel which adds some height without feeling unmanageable.

What the reviews say: “I have had these in three different colors over the years and wear them way too much. They go with everything and are super comfy and easy to walk in.” — Everlane

Naturalizer Darry Bootie

Sizes: 4 to 12 | Colors: 4 total, including Black and Cappuccino Brown | Materials: Leather or suede

Naturalizer specializes in different fits, ranging from wide calf boots to narrow calf boots. The Darry Bootie, in particular, has a cushioned footbed that hugs the contours of the foot and comes in both medium and wide widths.The side goring, insulated fabric lining and water-repellent exterior also add to the shoe’s overall wearability.

What the reviews say: “I just took these boots on a trip and wore them the entire weekend and was very impressed. They are surprisingly lightweight for a chunky boot, and I was able to walk all day (10k steps) in them comfortably. It also rained the entire trip and my feet stayed nice and dry.” — Naturalizer

Madewell The Darcy Ankle Boot

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 5 total, including Black and Silver | Materials: Leather

Ankle boots can sometimes cause rubbing, but Madewell’s Darcy Boots stand outs for being both comfortable and stylish. With a 2-inch stacked heel and extra padding that rivals your favorite sneaker, these shoes are ideal for work, fancy dinners and everything in between. Reviewers recommend going a half size up in you plan on wearing thicker socks.

What the reviews say: “I have been so pleased with Madewell boots over the years and these are no exception. They look great and are easy to break in. I also love that they are a bit higher on the ankle.” — Nordstrom

Vionic Lani Lace-Up Boot

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: 4 total, including Black and Olive | Materials: Leather or suede

With excellent traction, protective uppers (the shaft height measures 6.5-inches) and a lace-up design, this classic combat boot will take you from work to weekends. The rubber outsole is surprisingly lightweight, and reviewers say the leather is supportive without being stiff. Also good to know: These boots earned the American Podiatric Medical Association (APMA) Seal of Acceptance, which is awarded to products that can help maintain good foot health.

What the reviews say: “Extremely comfortable, and I could wear them for a long time the first time I put them on. I would highly recommend them.” — Amazon

Cole Haan Hampshire Buckle Bootie

Sizes: 5 to 11 | Colors: 3 total, including Black and British Tan | Materials: Leather or suede

When it comes to work and dress shoes, you want a pair that’s comfortable but still looks polished and professional. Cole Haan’s Hampshire Buckle Bootie ticks the boxes with its padded leather interior and clean lines. The 1.5-inch stacked heel is incredibly easy to walk in, and the gold side buckle adds some visual interest. Reviewers rave about the quality of the leather and appreciate that it pairs well with just about anything.

What the reviews say: “The color, the fit and the quality are fantastic. I am on my feet all day at work and they were so comfortable.” — Cole Haan

Sizes: 4.5 to 13 | Colors: 3 total, including Black and Ivory Birch | Materials: Leather

Chelsea boots are characterized by an ankle-skimming length, rounded toe, back pull tab and elastic panels on the sides for comfort and breathability. This pick’s design stays true to the original but adds a 2-inch heel and 1-inch platform for a slight lift. Despite the thick platform and block heel, the rubber outsole provides plenty of traction and the leather uppers protect you from the elements. Reviewers note that these shoes run large so you might want to size down.

What the reviews say: “I wore them for the first time and walked all night in them and it was like wearing a pair of sneakers. So comfortable and cute. I've sent more expensive boots back because of comfort or they look bad on and these are great it all those departments.” — Nordstrom

Aerosoles Binocular Knee High Boot

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 5 total, including Black and Brown | Materials: Faux leather or faux suede

Aerosoles’ Binocular Knee High Boot is a bestseller cut from smooth faux leather (or faux suede) with a tall shaft that looks elegant and sleek. The brand’s signature outsole, called the diamond flex outsole, drives friction away from the foot and provides grip for any environment.

What the reviews say: “Fantastic boots. Comfortable and go with all lengths of skirts/dresses as well as leggings and pants.” — Amazon

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 4 total, including Black and Burgundy | Materials: Calf leather

DuoBoots is a direct-to-consumer brand that handcrafts their shoes in Portugal using high-quality materials that are made to last—and not just for one season. All of their knee high boots, including the Verity Knee High Boot, come in eight different calf sizes (the DuoBoots Fit Finder can help you find the right size) and have a memory foam insole for all day comfort. The Verity is an equestrian-inspired boot, so it has a low heel and high shaft with an elasticated stretch panel that hugs the calf.

What the reviews say: “These boots are gorgeous and well worth their price tag. Fine quality leather in a beautiful brownish burgundy color and the fit is perfect on my calf. For the first time ever, boots that zip up without a struggle.” — DuoBoots

LifeStride Women's X-Anita Boot

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 4 total, including Black and Heather Grey | Materials: Synthetic

With two different widths to choose from—medium and wide—LifeStride’s X-Anita Boot provide breathing room and comfort. Similar to the Verity Knee High Boot, this riding shoe has a low heel, tall shaft (with a visible stretch panel) and rounded toe box that won’t pinch your feet. The side zipper and decorative buckle on this pair add extra interest to the classic design.

What the reviews say: “ They are super comfortable, even from the first wear. They are made for walking or standing. The fit is perfect. They are quality, affordable and adorable.” — Amazon

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 4 total, including Midnight and Scotch | Materials: Goat hide

Tecovas’ Jamie Boot is a comfortable cowboy option cut from goat hide, which softens over time and develop a rich patina or finish that appears after regular use and exposure to the elements. Cording, a technique where leather cord or fabric is sewn behind the leather to create a raised look, adds a unique and decorative element to these boots. Reviewers say they fit true to size and have a beautiful color that holds up to frequent wear.

What the reviews say: “They felt wonderful from the first time I put them on: absolutely no breaking-in necessary. The color is an added win. These are a joy to wear.” — Tecovas

Aerosoles Brandi Ankle Boot

Sizes: 5 to 12 | Colors: 8 total, including Black and Navy | Materials: Faux leather or faux suede

Although the materials used for this boot are not as durable as other picks on this list (it’s constructed from faux leather or faux suede), the Brandi Ankle Boot is a solid choice if you’re working with a budget. It comes in under $100 and the wedge heel is comfortable to walk in since it distributes weight evenly across the entire foot. The elastic stretch panel on the side and memory foam cushioning also up the comfort factor.

What the reviews say: “I have plantar fasciitis and need comfortable but stylish shoes. These are cute, warm, comfortable and best of all, I can wear them all day. They run a little big but it’s okay.” — Aerosoles